Creffield and the Holy Rollers made page one headlines from 1903 to 1907. When I was researching Holy Rollers: Murder and Madness in Oregon’s Love Cult I spent months transcribing hundreds of articles. I’m not sure why I was so obsessive. Maybe it was my way of immersing my self into a cult without joining one. Anyway, I’m posting them all for those who are really interested in the story, or are interested the history of journalism, or are interested in how a scandalous story played out in the "media" in a by gone era. Since I no doubt made typos and unconsciously corrected papers' typos, these web pages should not be cited in anything serious (e.g. your dissertation). For such projects they should only be used as starting points and you should refer to the original sources. If you want a shorter version of the story, buy my book. Enjoy.
August 4, 1904: Creffield Says He Is Entirely Purified
Joe Haege as Edmund Creffield
Oregon Daily Journal (Portland) 8/4/1904 p3
“I Know No Sin”--Apostle Creffield
“Joshua” of the Holy Rollers Says He Is Entirely Purified--Is Bound Over to the Grand Jury Without Trial.”
“I am now Joshua, high priest, and at some future time will become Elijah, the restorer, “said Edmund Creffield this morning as he sat waiting to be called before Municipal Judge Hogue, B. E. Starr being the complaining witness. My work is to lead the 12 tribes of Israel back to Jerusalem, where the restoration of all things will take place, and the millennium will dawn on earth, he concluded.
At that juncture Bailiff Goltz called the leader of the Holy Rollers from the side room and he was arraigned before Judge Hogue by Deputy District Attorney Haney. He insisted on waiting preliminary hearing and going before the grand jury, so Judge Hogue held him under $2,000 bond. He will in all probability have to remain in the county jail.
Creffield walked with a firm step this morning and stood erect without assistance before Judge Hogue. When he said he wished to waive examination he was asked if he realized the serious nature of the charge facing him, and replied that he was fully aware of the gravity of the situation. Creffield had just granted an interview, which is here published, and Judge Hogue, upon being told that the Holy Roller leader talked rationally and was apparently in his right mind, bound him over.
Creffield complained this morning of flimsy stories that have been published concerning him, saying he was willing to tell everything the public desires to know.
“I KNOW NO SIN.”
“I have a mighty work to accomplish,” said Creffield just before his arraignment. “That work I will accomplish as God directs. I cannot know what my lot will be, but whatever comes to me, that will I construe as God’s holy will. I went under the Hurt residence at Corvallis not knowing what would befall me; I know now that I was crucified there and my spirit, body and mind were purified. I now know no sin. I was there prepared for my future work which I know is to restore Israel to Jerusalem.
“What will I say if sent to the penitentiary for life? Why, that God wills it so, of course. I shall wait patiently his commands, and do whatsoever he says. I am ready to lay down my life for Him. Regarding the charges people make, I say they are false. I have been pure in all my teachings. The reason my followers are insane, as people say, is because they are being sanctified for Jesus’ sake. They are not crazy--they are bound up in the spirit of God for a purpose. People who are in darkness cannot comprehend the things of the light of the spirit; that is impossible.
DENIES PUBLISHED STORIES
“A great many cruel and false things have been published about me and my work, but excepting for the souls of those who have written the false tales, I do not care, for they are irresponsible, being of the world, the flesh and the devil. They cannot understand the great light of the truths of the spirit as I do and as my disciples do.”
Creffield said he felt fine this morning, and he looked it. Save for the paleness of face, brought on by his long sojourn under the Hurt residence, he appears well. He carried in his coat pocket the little volume of the scriptures, recently presented to him by O. V. Hurt.
During the proceedings this morning, B. E. Starr, with his wife sat and listened to all that was said. Mr. Starr says his wife still believes some portions of the Holy Roller teachings, but that she is now living with him and is not a fanatic. He says it would be all Creffield’s life is worth to again go to Corvallis.
West Side Enterprise (Independence, OR) 8/4/1904 p2
Edmund Creffield Alias “Elijah” Passed Through Independence Saturday. Was not Communicative, Carried no Alligator Grip, Silk Socks Nor Saratoga Trunk.
Edmund Creffield, of Holy Roller fame, spent a few minutes in Independence Saturday. He was aboard the Southern Pacific train and did not alight from his coach or stir from his seat. He was in custody of Detective Hartman of Portland, and deputy sheriff Wells of Benton County and was being escorted from Corvallis to Portland.
Through courtesy of the officers in charge, Creffield was asked by a representative of the West Side Enterprise if he still clings to his religious teachings that have attracted so much notoriety.
“It would be unjust to talk to reporters, in the sight of God,” was the reply.
“But if you have something good and we know nothing about it, you would not object to giving even reporters a few pointers,” ventured the interviewer.
“You’ll get pointers,” responded Creffield in a sarcastic tone, and these were the last words that could be drawn from the self-styled “Elijah.” He suddenly became mum as a Yaquina Bay oyster. Further questioning and the display of the warrant, but Detective Hartman, showing that the prisoner was held by virtue of a complaint of adultery, sworn out by B. E. Starr, only irritated to the leader of Holy Rollers. If remorse had ever taken him, bringing home the responsibility for breaking up homes, sending half a dozen people to the insane asylum, and others to the boys’ and girls’ aid society, he did not show it. He looked sorry that some one had pulled him from under the floor at Corvallis. He showed his displeasure at being questioned by restlessly looking to right and left alternately, in ill-concealed efforts to appear oblivious to his surroundings. There were no creases in Creffield’s pants, nor was his attire otherwise fashioned after a pattern plate. He carried no alligator grip with silk socks, sleeping gown, and change of linen nor Saratoga trunk with dress suits and French perfumes. With a slouched hat and clothes to match, and pallid complexion, he looked like one just released from a long jail sentence. His hands lay limp, and with a freshly shaven face and light eyes, his appearance was more that of a plant grown in the shade than a human being with red blood in his veins.
He was found under the house of O. V. Hurt at Corvallis last Friday.
(The usual story of finding Creffield under Hurt’s house)
HEADLINES IN DIFFERENT PAPERS FOR THE SAME ARTICLE
Evening Telegram (Portland) 8/4/1904 p1
Creffield To Answer
Holy Roller Prophet Does Not Attempt Any Defense. Says He Is Willing to Let the Lord Decide His Case. Judge Hogue Remands Him to Jail, Waiting Grand Jury.
Corvallis Times 8/6/1904 p3
HEADLINE IN ANOTHER PAPER FOR THE SAME ARTICLE, BUT MUCH ABRIDGED ARTICLE
Brownsville Times 8/12/1904 p1
To The Grand Jury
In Two Thousand Dollar Bonds Creffield in the Portland Courts.
[(Corvallis Times) Creffield has been bound over to await the action of the grand jury of the Multnomah County circuit court in $2,000 bonds. The grand jury will be in session in September. The action was taken in the police court in Portland Thursday. The story of the proceedings is told as follows in The Telegram: ]
“John Doe” Creffield, as he is known in the cold verbiage of the law; Edmund Creffield, as his mother christened him in the incipiency of his troubled career; “Joshua” the prophet, self-styled in the weird and fanatical fancy of the man whose deeds have shocked the religious world must go before the grand jury and answer to the charge of adultery, contrary to the laws of the land and the Decalogue of the books he worships. This man was brought before Judge Hogue in the Municipal Court this morning and upon waiving the right of a preliminary examination was bound over to the tender mercies of a higher court under $2000 bail. After this formal procedure this man who says he is a prophet was led back to the gloom of his prison cell.
The old dingy Police Court room was crowded to the doors all forenoon by a staring, morbid crowd, bent on catching a glance of the religious crank, who, fleeing from the demands of the law, skulked under the house of the man whose family he almost annihilated and starved himself to a pale and sickly wretch.
WOMEN CAME TO SEE HIM [Evening Telegram (Portland)]
Women there were in the usual number, some of whom were there as witnesses of this and other cases, and some who were said to be there for a look at Creffield. All morning the crowd hung around the courtroom, half of them unable to procure seats, but still they stayed until after the stroke of twelve when the “prophet” appeared, was led away and the court room cleared itself with a rush.
CALLED INTO THE COURT (Corvallis Times)
“Bring Creffield,” said Deputy District Attorney Haney, and there was a stir in the court room. “Come on, Creffield,” said the officer in waiting on the court as he beckoned to an invisible object in the culprit’s room, and immediately through the doorway emerged the form of the Holly Roller leader. Pale in complexion and insignificant in form, he walked slowly toward the bench upon which sat His Honor, Judge Hogue. The crowd stared and the eyes of B. E. Starr, the complaining witness, flashed the hatred he avows toward the man, charged with violating the sanctity of his home.
“Creffield, you are here to be given a hearing, do you want one?” queried Deputy District Attorney Haney, as the pale man leaned against the bar and roller his big eyes at the court on high.
WANTED NO HEARING [Evening Telegram (Portland)]
“No,” came the response in a weak voice.
“You want to waive a hearing then?” commented the prosecutor, and the pale man assented.
“Do you understand what is meant by waiving a hearing and going before the Grand Jury?” asked Judge Hogue from the bench, and Creffield said he did.
“You understand then, that you are to go before the Grand Jury when you leave this court? You are sane; you are not insane, are you?” asked the court.
Creffield blandly replied that he was not insane, and that he understood.
“You understand the charge that stands against you, do you not?” asked Judge Hogue.
“Yes, I understand,” came the weak voice of the “apostle” in returo (sic).
After a short conference between the court and the Deputy District Attorney the amount of bail was fixed at $2000, and Creffield was led to the waiting room to await transportation to the County Jail where he will languish until the sitting of the jury court in September.
PITIABLE SIGHT [Evening Telegram (Portland)]
It was a rather pitiable sight enacted in the courtroom, exemplary of the proverbial remark of the might fallen. There, under the sting and disgrace of a criminal charge, the center of morbid curiosity, and the contempt of the law, stood this man, who, but a few months before, held forth at the town of Corvallis--like a prince feeding upon the fat of the land as did Belshazzar of old--now forsaken per force by his erstwhile followers and locked in the confines of iron bars with common criminals.
“I shall not ask for a lawyer, but if the state demands that I have one, then it must be so,” said Creffield, after leaving the courtroom.
“How do you expect to receive justice without a lawyer” was asked.
“How do I expect to get justice? God will be with me all the time. If he desires to have me found guilty, I shall receive it joyfully. I have no feeling of animus toward anyone. I love all men with a divine love. Not as the world loves, but with a divine love. If they were to sentence me for life, hurt or kill me, I would still love them. all hatred has left me, but the world cannot understand this.”
When asked why Starr should have preferred against him the charge he has if he were not guilty, Creffield acted uneasy and replied that he did not know. He refused to talk on this point, but declared that he is not guilty of the crime charged.
CREFFIELD NOT INSANE
Creffield is not insane, but that he is a religious fanatic there is not the least doubt. He answers questions and carried on a conversation in a perfectly rational manner, but talks after the fashion of a pronounced fanatic when speaking of religion. He resents the story printed in the Telegram yesterday speculative as to his being possessed of hypnotic power. He declares that he knows nothing whatever of it. Knows nothing of the rudiments and has never practiced the art at all.
“I feel certain that Creffield has the power of hypnotism, or the ability of casting some strange influence over people,” said B. E. Starr, husband of Mrs. Donna Starr, the woman with whom the “apostle” is accused of criminal relations. “I am sure he has this power,” continued Starr, “because the people he has under his influence were good people and trying to do right.”
Starr says that his wife is gradually regaining her normal condition. She now eats pork, pickles and other edibles, forbidden by the Creffield creed. Her former coldness toward him, says Mr. Starr, is abated in a measure, although she still adheres to the faith and believes that she with all the other followers of this man, will have the power to cast out devils and perform other miracles, reputed of fact in Scriptural story.
Mr. Starr declares he believes his wife to be under hypnotic influence at the hands of Creffield.
HIS PAST HISTORY (Corvallis Times)
Some of the past history of Creffield has been dug up by the Portland newspapers. a sample of it is given in the following from the Portland Telegram:
(Excerpts from Evening Telegram (Portland) Wed 8/3/1904 p14)